If we can build it, we understand it… clearly we don’t understand life

This week in Pacific Standard I try to answer the question, why can’t we build life from scratch?

There are two primary ways biologists are trying to build life from scratch – evolution and intelligent design. People like Harvard’s Jack Szostak are trying to understand prebiotic evolution, by evolving autonomously replicating protocells in the lab. On the other hand, synthetic biologists, like those at the Venter Institute, want to be able to go to the whiteboard and intelligently design a genome from scratch. They already know how to synthesize and transplant a genome; designing it is another matter. As I wrote for Pacific Standard, we’re “like someone who knows how to work a 3-D printer but can’t design new digital templates for it.”

Will we ever solve this problem? I think the answer partly depends on whether life is just details, or whether there are some fundamental and precise principles that allow us to coarse grain our understanding in a way that lets us get past the details. To evolve life in the lab, does it require just hitting that sweet spot, that rare combination of chemical conditions we can only discover by trial and error, or are there principles? When we design a genome from scratch, is it all simply about the specificities, concentrations, and affinities of 100,000 different molecular species, or are there genuine design principles?

Currently, I’m a pessimist – I expect we’ll design life from scratch one day, but the solution will not be elegant; it will be done with brute force.


One response to “If we can build it, we understand it… clearly we don’t understand life

  1. The faith based myth of the atheist. Abiogenesis is a hypothesis that is unscientific and unsupported by any evidence!! The hypothesis teaches that life arose from inorganic dead chemicals which came to life over the course of one billion years!

    Atheists attempt to use in their desperation is “lab created RNA and protocells” as proof for abiogenesis.These experiments are highly orchestrated by very intelligent chemists, NOT unguided natrual chemical processes!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s